Traverse DeskGet COGO
Closure diagnosis

Use along-line and cross-line error to investigate a short distance

Project a 0.25 m traverse residual onto a suspect course and test whether a distance transcription could explain the direction of the gap.

Worked example42.55 m − 42.30 m = 0.25 m to test along the line
On this pageResolve the discrepancy into two directionsTry a second course before picking the culpritBuild a controlled test in the calculatorKeep the unit-vector calculation auditable

A half-erased distance in the field book reads either 42.30 or 42.55 m. The traverse misses closure by a quarter metre. Matching magnitudes make the longer reading tempting. Before changing anything, test a stronger prediction. A change in one straight distance moves the endpoint along that particular course. It cannot move it sideways.

Resolve the discrepancy into two directions

Take a synthetic loop whose computed endpoint lies 0.150 m north and 0.200 m east of its intended position. The suspect course runs on azimuth 53.130102°, a line with north and east unit components of 0.6 and 0.8. Those components describe the displacement for one metre along the course. Their squares add to one.

Project the endpoint discrepancy onto the course. Multiply each component by the matching component of the unit direction, then add. The result is 0.150 × 0.6 + 0.200 × 0.8 = 0.250 m. A positive result means the endpoint lies forward along that line from where you expected it.

Now project onto the right-hand perpendicular. With coordinates ordered north, east, that unit vector is (−0.8, +0.6). The second projection is −0.150 × 0.8 + 0.200 × 0.6 = 0.000 m. All of the discrepancy lies along the suspect bearing. If that single distance really was transcribed too long, shortening it by 0.250 m would remove this particular discrepancy.

Try a second course before picking the culprit

Suppose another poorly written distance belongs to a due-east line. Its unit direction is (0, 1). The same discrepancy projects 0.200 m along that course and −0.150 m to its right, since right of east is south. Even removing 0.200 m of length leaves the northward component untouched. That entry alone cannot explain the complete vector.

A parallel course on the first bearing would produce exactly the same direction signature. A course pointing the opposite way could produce it with the opposite sign of distance error. Use the analysis to rank pages of the notebook for review. The field note, original instrument record, or repeat measurement supplies the evidence for making a correction.

Build a controlled test in the calculator

The following four lines represent two pairs of oppositely directed, nominally equal courses. The first course contains the extra quarter metre.

53.130102, 42.55
143.130102, 28
233.130102, 42.30
323.130102, 28

Paste them into the loop calculator. First verify that the gap reads 0.250 m and the perimeter is 140.850 m. Shorten the first distance in this training example to 42.30. The loop closes at computational precision and the perimeter drops by 0.250 m. Changing just the perpendicular side produces a very different result. An added quarter metre there moves the endpoint sideways and increases the overall gap to roughly 0.354 m.

Keep the unit-vector calculation auditable

Write a small two-row worksheet. On the first row store the endpoint error in northing and easting. On the second store cosine and sine of the course azimuth, using radians for spreadsheet trigonometric functions. Retain the azimuth as recorded and round the projected distances at the end. Check that the sum of the squared projections equals the squared original gap. Here 0.250² + 0² equals 0.150² + 0.200².

For real work, preserve a copy of the original computation. Add the alternative reading to a second column with the predicted along-line change and the measured cross-line remainder. If several alternatives fit, write that down. A mathematically neat interpretation has genuine value when it tells a crew which observation to check again.

When the cross-line remainder is on the same scale as the original gap, prioritize angle or station checks before treating the distance as the whole explanation. When it is small, use the along-line amount to specify exactly which alternative distance the original record should support.

References

Check traverses offline with COGO