Traverse DeskGet COGO
Closure diagnosis

What a traverse precision ratio actually measures

Calculate the 1:n denominator from a measured loop, compare two routes with the same gap, and distinguish relative precision from positional accuracy.

Worked example500.070 m ÷ 0.050 m = 10,001.4
On this pageRebuild the denominator from the observationsCompare two traverses with the same gapWhy a larger number can hide a poor surveyDecide what to put on the review sheet

A crew reports a 50 mm gap. The drawing gives you no perimeter. Before you decide what the number means, ask how far the traverse traveled. A 50 mm discrepancy after 500 m gives a different relative precision from the same discrepancy after 125 m. Both gaps would look identical on a detail drawn around the closing station.

Rebuild the denominator from the observations

Use this synthetic straight-sided loop. Bearings are clockwise azimuths and lengths are horizontal metres. Paste the four lines into the closure calculator and select metres.

0, 150.030
90, 100.040
180, 150.000
270, 100.000

The northward excess is 0.030 m and the eastward excess is 0.040 m. The gap is the diagonal of that small rectangle. Its length is √(0.030² + 0.040²), which gives exactly 0.050 m for these inputs. The observations total 500.070 m. Dividing 500.070 by 0.050 gives 10,001.4. To the nearest whole denominator the display reads 1:10,001.

Keep both inputs in the same unit for the division. Dividing 500.070 metres by 50 millimetres produces a plausible-looking 10.0014 with a thousandfold scale error. Expressing everything in millimetres gives 500,070 divided by 50, recovering the original answer. That unit cancellation is one reason the ratio travels well in a field report.

Compare two traverses with the same gap

For a shorter loop, change the north and south nominal lengths to 37.5 m and the east and west lengths to 25 m. Keep the 0.030 and 0.040 excesses on the outward observations. The perimeter becomes 125.070 m and the same 0.050 m gap gives about 1:2,501. The shorter circuit’s gap occupies a larger fraction of its measured length.

Quantity Long circuit Short circuit
Measured length 500.070 m 125.070 m
Linear misclosure 0.050 m 0.050 m
Misclosure per kilometre 0.100 m 0.400 m

The last row uses the unrounded ratio and rounds to the nearest millimetre per kilometre. It is an alternate expression of the observed fraction. It does not predict an error at every kilometre along a line. One short sight could account for almost all of the gap.

Why a larger number can hide a poor survey

Imagine turning every bearing in the long example by five degrees. The drawing rotates rigidly, but lengths and the tiny gap magnitude remain the same. A traverse can pass a loop test and miss a known monument by metres because the starting orientation is wrong. A uniform translation of every coordinate is invisible to this test as well. To check placement, introduce an independent point or direction that did not participate in computing the traverse.

Using the coordinates after a mathematical adjustment would make the fraction look better again. Record the result from the unadjusted observations, with any documented instrument and reduction corrections already applied. Store the adjustment report separately so someone can recover the actual check.

Decide what to put on the review sheet

Write the perimeter, the two signed component sums, the linear misclosure and the ratio on the same line. Add the observation unit and identify the control used. Where a contract specifies a threshold, compare against the unrounded fraction in the form the contract requires. A formatted denominator can round to the threshold even when the underlying result falls slightly short.

If the software reports closure at calculation precision, retain the underlying input precision in the notes. Entering four perfect right angles and equal opposite sides can produce a numerical zero from rounded field-book values. A numerical zero alone cannot establish the accuracy of the original observations.

References

Check traverses offline with COGO